Science Fiction and Fantasy Community Forums

Full Version: Slavery in Harry Potter
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Hagrid told Hermione that freeing the house elves would do them injustice since it was for their own good the same way people thought of black people in the US.
I'm not sure J.K. Rowling handled that discussion well. On the one hand, we must concede that someone had to make the specious argument. And Hermione wasn't likely to have a rational argument with anyone from the deeply conservative families. On the other hand, Hagrid's explanation draws attention to something about Wizard society that isn't good and acceptable.

Even the "good" wizard-folk are not perfect. And that's important.

But it also highlights Hagrid's own oppressed status. And it would have been ideal for someone to help Hagrid see that he needed to update his views on what was best for the various creatures of the world. But I think a major theme throughout the books is that the human magic-using community is an oppressive civilization in need of severe change. In a way, having the Death-eaters take over and start persecuting magic-using folks was Rowling's way of saying, "People who think this way eventually eat their own."

That's a real problem in every society that establishes a social barrier. One of the most extreme examples in history was the City of Sparta. They were considered the best soldiers in the world, but by the time they were overcome by the Romans they had so alienated their own people that they could only muster 1,000 Spartan soldiers. All their supporters (many of whom were descended from former Spartan citizens who had been expelled for various infractions of Spartan law and custom) turned against them.

So I don't think Hagrid was supposed to represent the "right" point of view - I think he was supposed to highlight how rational thought had all but been abandoned by even the "good" folk. Hermione brought a fresh perspective to the conversation, one that probably hadn't been heard for generations. But maybe Hagrid wasn't the best character to represent the wrong-sided point of view.